Call us: +31 85 060 64 99

info@arbeidsadvocaat.nl

Operates Nationwide

Can you terminate an employee’s employment if they are in custody?

Introduction

When an employee is in pretrial detention or serving a prison sentence, this raises questions about the employment relationship. Termination is not always immediately possible. This blog explains the legal steps employers can take and the factors judges consider when ruling on termination during detention.

Dismissal During Pretrial Detention

If an employee is in custody because he is suspected of a criminal offense, dismissal is not automatically permitted. Under the law, the presumption is that a person is innocent until proven guilty. As long as there is only a suspicion, an employer generally cannot terminate the employee’s employment immediately. In this situation, it makes more sense to temporarily suspend pay, since the employee is unable to perform their duties.

Dismissal Following a Conviction

If an employee has been convicted and must actually serve a prison sentence, summary dismissal may be considered. However, this is not automatically permitted. A well-known court ruling shows that the court applies strict standards. In a case involving a financial employee of ABN AMRO who had been convicted of sexual abuse of his stepson, the Supreme Court ruled that the summary dismissal was not legally valid. The criminal offense took place entirely in the private sphere, had no impact on the employee’s job performance, and the employer had not suffered any direct damage.

Dismissal through the small claims court

When immediate termination is not possible, an employer may file a petition for termination with the small claims court. In such cases, the judge weighs the interests involved. Factors considered include the length of the incarceration, the nature of the criminal offense, and the consequences for the company. The likelihood that the request will be granted is particularly high when there is a clear connection between the employee’s work and the criminal offense—for example, in the case of a driver convicted of driving under the influence.

No obligation to keep the workspace clear

Case law further establishes that an employer is not obligated to keep an employee’s position open if the employee is incarcerated for an extended period—for example, more than two years. Here, too, a careful and proper approach is essential to avoid legal risks.

Conclusion
Dismissal following detention is legally complex. Suspicion alone is insufficient grounds for immediate termination; following a conviction, the judge will determine whether the criminal offense has implications for the employment contract. A careful approach is essential to prevent errors and legal claims.


This blog was written by Stijn Blom, Esq., an employment law attorney at Arbeidsadvocaat.nl B.V. Stijn has extensive experience in employment law and assists business owners on a daily basis with a wide range of employment law issues. From dismissal cases to drafting watertight contracts and policies—with his practical and personalized approach, he helps employers and employees move forward. Want to learn more? Visit Stijn’s page.

Arbeidsadvocaat.nl is happy to help you if you have any questions about XXX. Please feel free to contact us .

April 2025